Revenue is 20% behind plan. Why?
How VCmind and its agents help a portfolio company that has fallen behind plan.*
The context
Halden Pay, a portfolio company, sells software to mid-size banks. Its monthly update shows revenue 20% behind plan, and the CEO's email doesn't say why. The partner asks VCmind and its AI agents to find out. Within a few hours, the AI agents find the causes and prepare the help.
What happened, step by step
Monday morning
The update arrives
Halden Pay's monthly update shows revenue 20% behind plan. The CEO's email gives no reason. The partner asks VCmind's AI agents, called Spencer's team: why?
Monday, within the hour
The evidence
Spencer's team gathers what the firm already has: Halden's last two board decks, with their sales pipeline and churn figures, and the CEO's updates and emails since August. They also check the price pages of Halden's rivals, their public news as well as client reviews over the internet.
Monday afternoon
The likely causes, tested
Spencer tests three possible causes. Big deals with banks now take 121 days to close, up from 74. A rival cut its prices by 20% in September and is winning the smaller deals. Customers leaving is not the cause: churn is steady at 1.1% a month.
Monday evening
The partner gets the answer
Spencer sends the VC partner a short diagnosis: the most likely causes, how sure he is about each, and the help we can provide effectively. That help is introductions to the heads of IT at mid-size banks, led by Sarah, the VC partner who knows them best.
Same Monday evening
The help is ready
Spencer's team finds 17 people in the firm's network who know heads of IT at mid-size banks, and drafts three introduction emails, each in the voice of the partner who knows that person best. Nothing is sent until that partner approves.
What Spencer's team does in this case
What they read
- KPI misses against planRevenue, conversion, churn, margin and burn.
- Operating dataPipeline, sales cycle, contract value, headcount and customer concentration.
- History and commitmentsBoard notes, earlier plans, past quarters and what management promised.
- The marketCompetitor moves, price changes and shifts in demand.
- What the founder saysFounder updates, emails and meeting notes.
What they do
- 1Find the main performance problem
- 2Separate the symptom from the cause
- 3Compare with history, the plan and peers
- 4Test each likely cause and rate the evidence
- 5Recommend the help that would change the most
What you get
- The causeWhy the company is behind, with the evidence and how sure Spencer is.
- Questions for the CEOWhat to ask before deciding what to do.
- The help, preparedIntroductions, candidates or investors, drafted for approval.
- Who should helpWhich partner, and why: who knows whom, and how well.
An example of a diagnosis your partner receives
Diagnosis · Halden Pay · revenue 20% behind plan
The numbers · this month's update
- Revenue against plan
- −20%
- Days to close a big deal
- 121was 74
- Churn a month
- 1.1%
The likely causes, and how sure Spencer is
- Big deals with banks take longer to closeVery likely121 days now, up from 74
- A rival cut its prices by 20% in SeptemberLikelyIt is winning the smaller deals
- Customers leavingRuled outChurn is steady at 1.1% a month, so it is not the cause
The help that would change the most · led by Sarah
- Introductions to the heads of IT at mid-size banksSarah knows them best17 people in the firm's network can help
Questions to ask the CEO
- 1Which bank deals slipped this quarter, and what are the buyers waiting for?
- 2How will you respond to the rival's price cut on smaller deals?
Evidence: the last two board decks, founder emails of 3 and 17 October, competitor pricing pages, news and reviews.
The help, prepared
Spencer's team searches the firm's network for people who know heads of IT at mid-size banks, and drafts each introduction in the voice of the partner who knows them best.
Introductions · Halden Pay needs heads of IT at banks
Who can introduce Halden · 17 found, the best 3 here
- Sarah Lindqvist → CIO, NorthbankStrongLast spoke 32 days ago
- James Okafor → Chief Data Officer, Carrow BankMediumMet twice this year
- CEO of Copperline Labs (portfolio) → Head of Technology, Lindell & CoVery strongWorked together for 6 years
Help prepared · waiting for approval
- 3 introduction emails, one in each partner's voiceNothing is sent until each partner approves
Searched partners' email, the CRM, contact lists, shared LinkedIn connections, LPs, advisers and portfolio founders.
* This case is to show what Spencer’s team can do. Names are for illustration only.
Want this for your fund?
Use it for 2 months. See the value for yourself.
We'll implement VCmind around your existing investment process and technology stack.
You can use it for 60 days, and if you don't see meaningful value for your investment team, just cancel and we'll refund 100% of everything you've paid us. No implementation fee. No long-term commitment.