The numbers look fine. Is the company still winning?
How VCmind and its agents keep watch over your portfolio companies and prepare you for their boards.*
The context
Tidewell's numbers look like most months: revenue a little ahead of plan, burn slightly over budget, one senior role still unfilled. Nothing asks for a partner's attention. Nine days before the board meeting, your AI partner, Spencer from VCmind, finds that two of the three reasons the firm invested are weakening, prepares the human partner, and follows through after the board.
From an ordinary month to a prepared board
What happened, step by step, from the day the firm invested to the board meeting and the month after. Nothing on the dashboard turned red.
18 months before the board
Why the firm invested
Tidewell sells software that helps mid-size warehouses plan when trucks arrive and leave. The firm invested for three reasons. First, warehouses buy this kind of software as a separate product. Second, Tidewell is connected to more than 100 trucking companies, which is hard for rivals to copy. Third, customers stay for years and add more warehouses.
Every month since the investment
The dashboard looks normal
Revenue is 4% ahead of plan. Burn is 5% over budget because two engineers joined early. The usual mix for a company at this stage, and nothing that asks for a partner's attention.
2 months before the board
The market moves
Most warehouses Tidewell sells to are run on Shelfwise, a popular warehouse management system. Shelfwise announces that, from January, it will include a free tool for planning trucks. Spencer's team reads the news and sees the risk: warehouses may stop paying for Tidewell's software separately. That is the first reason for the investment, weakening.
6 weeks before the board
A rival catches up
Brightdock, Tidewell's closest rival, raises $40M and buys a company that is already connected to trucking companies. Brightdock is now connected to most of the same trucking companies as Tidewell. That is the second reason, weakening.
3 weeks before the board
The numbers behind the numbers
Spencer's team reads the sales figures in Tidewell's last two board decks. Revenue is up only because existing customers added more warehouses. Winning new customers has become much harder: when a warehouse already uses Shelfwise, Tidewell now wins 22% of the deals it bids for, down from 45%.
9 days before the board
The partner hears it first
Spencer sends the partner a short brief for the board meeting. It explains that two of the three reasons for the investment are weakening, shows the evidence and where each fact comes from, and suggests the questions to ask the CEO.
The day of the board
The right conversation
The partner starts the meeting with the change in the market, not with the dashboard. The board agrees on three actions, each with one person responsible and a deadline.
The month after the board
Follow-through and help
Spencer's team checks progress on the three actions and warns the partner when one falls behind. They also prepare help: an introduction to the person who runs partnerships at Shelfwise, and three candidates for a new head of partnerships at Tidewell. A partner at the firm approves every message before it is sent on the firm's behalf.
What Spencer's team does in this case
What they read
- Founder updates and board decksAs founders send them today, by email or through your portfolio tool.
- Your portfolio toolStandard Metrics, Visible, Vestberry, Rundit or Carta, if you use one.
- Plans and commitmentsBudgets, milestones agreed at investment and promises from the last board.
- Competitors and the marketRounds, launches, price changes, new entrants and senior hires.
- Public signalsHiring, web traffic and news, for companies that stop reporting.
What they do
- 1Pull out the numbers and match them to each company
- 2Check each company against its plan and its peers
- 3Track what competitors and the market are doing
- 4Flag what changed and what needs a partner
- 5Prepare the board meeting and follow up afterwards
What you get
- Early flagsRunway, burn, revenue against plan, and competitive threats, with the evidence.
- Board briefsWhat changed, what was promised, and the questions to ask.
- Commitment trackingDecisions, owners and dates after every board meeting.
- The portfolio reviewEvery company against plan, peers and competitors, for the partners' meeting.
An example of a board brief your partner receives
Board brief · Tidewell · 9 days before the board
The dashboard · nothing alarming
- Revenue against plan
- +4%
- Burn against budget
- +5%
- Churn a month
- 1.1%
- Runway
- 19 months
Why we invested versus the current situation
- Warehouses buy this software separatelyWeakeningShelfwise will include a free truck-planning tool from January.
- Links to 100+ trucking companies keep rivals outWeakeningBrightdock raised $40M and bought a company with the same links.
- Customers stay and add warehousesHoldingCustomers spend 28% more each year than the year before.
What the growth is hiding
Revenue is up only because existing customers added warehouses. When a warehouse already uses Shelfwise, Tidewell now wins far fewer new deals:
Questions to ask the CEO
- 1Which prospects said Shelfwise's free tool is good enough, and why?
- 2Could Tidewell sell through Shelfwise instead of against it?
- 3What does next year look like if new-customer growth halves?
Built from the IC memo, the last two board decks, founder updates, your data provider, news and rivals' websites. Every line links to its source.
After the board, Spencer follows through
Each decision gets an owner and a date, and Spencer's team tracks it until it is done. They flag what slips and line up the help the firm offered. Every introduction waits for a partner's approval.
After the board · Tidewell · 2 weeks later
What the board agreed · 3 actions
- Report new deals won each month, with and without ShelfwiseOn trackCFO · first report sent
- Apply to join Shelfwise's partner programOn trackCEO · by 15 November
- Hire a head of partnershipsAt riskCEO · by 31 January · no shortlist yet
Help prepared · waiting for approval
- An introduction to the head of partnerships at Shelfwise, through the CEO of one of your portfolio companiesEmail drafted for you
- Three candidates for Tidewell's head of partnerships, from the firm's network, each with the reason they fitShortlist ready for you
Each message is drafted in the voice of the partner who sends it, and waits for that partner's approval.
* This case is to show what Spencer’s team can do. Names are for illustration only.
Want this for your fund?
Use it for 2 months. See the value for yourself.
We'll implement VCmind around your existing investment process and technology stack.
You can use it for 60 days, and if you don't see meaningful value for your investment team, just cancel and we'll refund 100% of everything you've paid us. No implementation fee. No long-term commitment.